Date added:January 31, 2016
Download -250KBMuch of the literature on accountability focuses on citizen voices, but this article argues that there is a need to bring more of the state back into the equation. Here the authors chose to look at the state and see when and how it listens, to which actors; and why, at times, it chooses not to listen.
The article looks at four cases of key historical policies in Ghana (national health insurance), Kenya (digitalisation of governance), South Africa (social protection) and Tanzania (primary education), to examine how states engage with citizen voices. The policies all took place in contexts of political change and major junctures of democratisation.
The authors identify three kinds of moments when the state listens:
- Hearing moments, when it engages with citizen voices but does not change the way it acts
- Consultation moments, when it engages with citizen voices through two-way dialogue, resulting in one-sided action, and:
- Concertation moments, when coalitions between reform-minded officials and politicians and organised citizen voices engage in two-way dialogue and action for accountable governance.
Concertation moments occurred when there was a shared sense of urgency and a common goal across state and non-state actors, and despite different understandings of accountable governance. But concertation moments are also laborious and temporary, part of larger, ever-changing policy processes, and often states revert to consultation or hearing.
IDS Bulletin 47.1 Opening Governance
Download -250KB
About this publication
Publication type Journal article
Publication year2016
Page length16 pages
Keywordsaccountable governance, democracy, governance, political change, state responsiveness
Download -250KBTheme Citizen engagement and voice Civil society advocacy Civil society monitoring Open and responsive government Open data Transparency
Country Ghana Kenya South Africa Tanzania
Related content
-
PROJECT |June 7, 2016
When does the state listen? -
PUBLICATION |November 30, 2016
What happens when policy champions move on? The case of… -
PUBLICATION |November 30, 2016
Has Kenya's ICT revolution triggered more citizen participation? -
PUBLICATION |November 30, 2016
How does government responsiveness come about? The politics of accountability… -
PUBLICATION |June 15, 2016
Why is it so hard for non-state actors to be…
More on these themes
-
PUBLICATION |January 12, 2018
The Free State Housing Campaign: supporting people-led demands for social… -
BLOG |December 13, 2017
Supporting local learning and adaptation – Unpacking the effectiveness of… -
NEWS |November 15, 2017
LENGGO: Public budget tracking holds Kenyan county governments to account -
BLOG |November 14, 2017
Citizen accountability in a time of Facebook -
NEWS |October 23, 2017
Oil Journey: Following the money from oil revenue to improve…